Connecting the Dots: Organizing Schools Around the Student Experience
Think about a student in your school and all the people who contribute to their experience. There are classroom teachers, counselors, advisors, intervention specialists, and perhaps community partners or after-school staff. Each person plays an important role, and each brings a different understanding of what that student needs. But how often do those people have an opportunity to look at the student’s experience together?
OBJECTIVES
- Stronger connections across student supports
- Clearer understanding of student needs
- Better coordination of existing resources
We sometimes describe large comprehensive high schools as collections of independent contractors working independently. We have talented educators doing important work, but they’re often doing that work within their own classrooms, departments, or programs. Meanwhile, students move through seven, eight, or nine different environments, navigating different expectations and relationships. They may receive academic support in one setting, participate in a career pathway in another, and work with an after-school partner somewhere else. Each experience may be valuable, but that doesn’t mean those efforts are connected.
The question isn’t whether individual educators or programs are doing good work. It’s whether we’ve been intentional about connecting that work so students experience something coherent throughout their day. What would happen if we brought the people supporting one student together and asked them to look at the whole experience, rather than just their individual piece of it?
We could begin to see how our people, structures, resources, and opportunities fit together from the student’s perspective. More importantly, we could identify where those connections need to be stronger and make shared commitments to improve them.
Organizing Around the Student Experience
We invest in attendance strategies, literacy interventions, multilingual learner services, career pathways, and expanded learning opportunities. But having those supports in place doesn’t necessarily mean they’re connected or that students experience them in the ways we intend.
What does it look like through the students’ eyes?
–John Hattie
One way to address that is to organize our efforts around one learner. Bring together adults who know the student or influence their experience, including people from different classrooms, programs, and support roles. Start with what they know about the student’s strengths, interests, relationships, and daily experiences. Then look at where their efforts reinforce one another, where barriers exist, and what they can do differently together.
A focused 90-minute conversation can help turn those different perspectives into a shared plan. Rather than leaving with separate lists of responsibilities, the team identifies a common focus, a few commitments the student will actually experience, and a way to check whether those changes are working.
Organize the System Around One Learner: A 90-Minute Team Conversation
Imagine a student whose attendance has declined. Their advisor knows they’ve been missing school, a literacy specialist knows they’re struggling to access grade-level texts, a pathway coordinator knows they’re interested in a health career, and an after-school partner knows transportation is keeping them from attending tutoring.
Each person has a piece of the picture. Together, they can recognize how those challenges intersect and coordinate literacy support, pathway engagement, transportation, and trusted adult relationships. Instead of leaving with disconnected tasks, they can agree on a shared focus and a few commitments the student will actually experience.
Seeing What Students Actually Experience
Even when we bring the right people together, we may not have a complete picture of what students encounter throughout their day. Sometimes we need to hear directly from students and families. Other times, observing students across classrooms and settings can reveal patterns we wouldn’t otherwise recognize.
Empathy interviews are another valuable way to better understand the student experience. By asking open-ended questions and listening with curiosity, we can learn how students feel as they navigate their school day, where they experience connection and support, and what challenges they face. These conversations can reveal insights that help us see the school through students’ eyes and identify opportunities for meaningful change. Check out this toolkit to learn more about empathy interviews.
I saw just how revealing that perspective can be when I worked with a high school that was trying to build greater alignment around literacy instruction. The leadership team wanted teachers to commit to a handful of common literacy strategies across classrooms, but they needed a way to help staff understand why that mattered.
Rather than starting with another presentation about literacy data, we had teachers follow six students through a full school day. Over three days, teachers quietly observed students with different academic experiences and learning needs, looking for evidence of explicit literacy instruction and opportunities to engage in reading and writing.
What they found was remarkable. Across the school day, students spent very little time engaged in developing or using literacy strategies. Even more striking, students in advanced programming received more explicit literacy instruction than students with specific language disabilities. The students who needed the most intentional support were receiving fewer opportunities to develop those skills.
I don’t think anyone intended for that to happen. Teachers cared about their students, and the school had invested in literacy development. But until they looked across students’ full days, they didn’t have a clear picture of what was happening.
That became a significant aha moment for the staff. Instead of debating whether they needed common literacy strategies, they had firsthand evidence of how inconsistent the student experience was. It moved the conversation from what we believed we were providing to what students were actually experiencing.
The same questions apply to how we organize schools, not just how we teach. I once spoke with an educator who described middle school as one of the most challenging environments to lead. Their district had moved sixth graders into middle schools serving grades six through eight but retained a junior high structure rather than organizing students into housed teams. Young adolescents were navigating six or seven different adult relationships, classroom expectations, and transitions every day.
I suggested following a student who was struggling through a full school day. What might we learn about the noise, transitions, expectations, and relationships that student was navigating? Where did the school’s structure create consistency, and where might it be making an already challenging experience more difficult?
Whether we’re examining literacy instruction or the structure of a school day, the lesson is the same. We can’t assume that because a support exists, students can access it or experience it as intended. A student may have tutoring available but no way to attend, or several adults monitoring their progress without those adults ever connecting what they know. Understanding those realities helps us make better decisions about how to organize our efforts.
One Student Can Reveal Opportunities for the Whole School
Although we begin with one learner, the value doesn’t end with that student’s coordination plan. Looking closely at one experience can reveal patterns that affect many students. Maybe several supports are available, but no one is connecting them. Maybe expectations vary significantly across classrooms. Perhaps a strong practice in one setting isn’t reaching students elsewhere.
This is particularly relevant for schools and districts working to bring a graduate portrait or shared vision for student readiness to life. If collaboration, communication, belonging, and career readiness are priorities, we should be able to see those priorities reflected in students’ daily experiences.
One way to explore that connection is through a Campus Ghostwalk. This activity invites teams to walk through classrooms, gathering areas, and other campus spaces, looking for evidence of their school’s guiding principles. What messages are students receiving from their environment? Where do our spaces reinforce what we value, and where might they be sending conflicting messages?
A fresh look at our campus can reveal messages we might otherwise overlook. By examining the spaces students use every day, we can identify where our guiding principles are visible, where they may be missing, and what changes could make our shared values more evident throughout the school.
But the physical environment is only one part of the picture. Are academic supports reinforcing students’ interests and aspirations? Are adults coordinating relationships in ways that help students feel connected? Are students encountering consistent opportunities to develop the skills we’ve identified as important?
From Good Intentions to Shared Commitments
The goal isn’t to collect observations, have an interesting conversation, and return to business as usual. The value comes from making commitments that change what students experience.
There’s a difference between saying, “The literacy team will coordinate with the pathway department,” and saying, “The reading support this student receives will help them access the texts they’re encountering in their health pathway.” The first describes an adult task. The second describes a meaningful change for the student.
Those commitments also need to account for practical realities. A plan that depends on a family overcoming transportation, scheduling, or language barriers without additional support may look coordinated on paper but still fail the student.
We don’t need to solve everything at once. Identify one high-leverage adjustment the team can make within two to four weeks, clarify who’s responsible, and come back together to see whether it’s making a difference. That creates a manageable starting point and an opportunity to keep learning.
The Measure of Alignment Is What Students Experience
As school leaders, we spend a lot of time thinking about instructional programs, staffing structures, schedules, student supports, partnerships, and improvement plans. But students don’t experience those things as separate systems. They experience a school day, with all its relationships, opportunities, expectations, and barriers.
I’d encourage you to identify one student whose experience could help your team see the system differently. Bring together a manageable group of adults who know that student or influence their experience. Start with the student’s strengths, map what’s happening, and identify where your efforts could be better connected. Then make a few commitments, choose one meaningful adjustment, and return to see what has changed.
You might discover that the most important next step isn’t adding another program or initiative. It may be helping the people and supports you already have work together more intentionally.
The measure of a coherent school isn’t how many supports we’ve created or how clearly we’ve articulated our priorities. It’s whether those efforts come together in ways that make a meaningful difference in students’ daily experiences. And sometimes, the best way to improve the whole system is to start by organizing it around one learner.
Responses